Cedarhurst, NY · Since 1977

Bottled Iced Coffee

Brewed from premium beans, naturally flavored, never sweetened — and always made to order. Choose from 88 flavor options, available in three sizes plus ground and whole bean. Nationwide shipping.

  • 88 Flavors
  • Made to Order
  • 0 Added Sugar
  • Vaad Certified
59 Oz Iced Coffee Bottle The Cheese Store Cedarhurst

59 Oz. Bottled Iced Coffee

$18.50

32 Oz Iced Coffee Bottle The Cheese Store Cedarhurst

32 Oz. Bottled Iced Coffee

$12.50

16 Oz. Iced Coffee Bottle

16 Oz. Bottled Iced Coffee

$6.50

Ground/Whole Bean Coffee

Ground Coffee

From $10.00

Whole Bean Coffee

Whole Bean Coffee

From $9.00

Fan Favorites

Named by the people who drink them

Some combinations got their names because a customer kept ordering them until we wrote it on the board. Others came from staff testing what pairs well with what. These four earned their spots.

Customer Favorite

The BOOM

Vanilla Almond + Caramel + Hazelnut

The most-ordered blend in the collection.

Customer Favorite

Carajigama

Nestle Crunch + Vanilla

Two ingredients that shouldn't work. They do.

Customer Favorite

Best. Coffee. Ever.

Vanilla + Hazelnut + Cinnamon

Bold claim. Loyal following.

Staff Pick

Mike Special

English Toffee + Vanilla + Caramel

Perfected by a staff member over many visits.

See all 20+ signature combinations

Good to Know

Common questions

How long does bottled iced coffee stay fresh?

Refrigerated and unopened, our bottled iced coffee stays fresh for up to two weeks. Once opened, finish within 5–7 days for the best flavor. Keep it cold.

Can I mix multiple flavors in one bottle?

Yes. Every bottle is made to order, and you can mix up to three flavors per bottle from our 88-flavor menu. Or try one of our 20+ signature combinations built by staff and customers.

How many servings does a 59oz bottle make?

About 5–6 servings at 10 ounces per cup. A 32oz bottle serves around 3. A 16oz bottle is roughly 1.5 servings. For events larger than 10 people, use our coffee calculator or call the store.

Do you ship nationwide?

Yes. Our bottled iced coffee ships throughout the continental United States. Local pickup is available at our Cedarhurst store, and local delivery in the Five Towns is available through Sauce.

Is your coffee kosher?

Yes. All our coffee — bottled, ground, and whole bean — is certified kosher under the Vaad HaKashrus of the Five Towns and Far Rockaway. Both caffeinated and decaffeinated options are available.

Need help deciding?

—